Fix command accuracy against real rtk-ai/rtk (#2)

Correct references to commands/flags that don't exist in real RTK so the
agent isn't told to run failing commands, and fix the hook framing.

- Remove `rtk tree` (use `rtk ls`), `rtk gain --failures` (use `rtk discover`
  + the real [tee] mode="failures" fallback), and `rtk json --keys-only`.
- Clarify that `rtk init` does not target Command Code yet, so manual AGENTS.md
  prefixing is the working default.
- Soften "lossless" to "signal-preserving" to match RTK's filter-plus-tee
  behavior.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01VvpBXNCbbg4eibmZQZAbb6

Author: Coding-Dev-Tools

AGENTS.md

@@ -17,7 +17,7 @@ the tiers in @references/commands.md.
 ## The one rule: compress noise, preserve signal
 
 Use `rtk <cmd>` when output is **large, repetitive, low-stakes** — skim, not
-study: `rtk ls`, `rtk tree`, `rtk git status`, `rtk git log`, `rtk docker ps`,
+study: `rtk ls`, `rtk git status`, `rtk git log`, `rtk docker ps`,
 `rtk pip list`, and big test/build runs (`rtk cargo test`, or `rtk err <cmd>` —
 RTK keeps the failures and drops the green).
 
@@ -33,15 +33,15 @@ When unsure, start raw. Lean context comes from cutting *noise*, not *signal*.
 
 ## Never default to lossy modes
 
-Plain `rtk <cmd>` is near-lossless (keeps errors, diffs, stack traces, exit
-codes). `-u` / `--ultra-compact`, `rtk read … -l aggressive`, and `rtk smart`
+Plain `rtk <cmd>` keeps the signal — errors, diffs, stack traces, exit codes —
+and strips only noise. `-u` / `--ultra-compact`, `rtk read … -l aggressive`, and `rtk smart`
 (2-line summary) are **lossy** — opt-in only for skimming something huge and
 unimportant, never your default.
 
 ## If a compressed view isn't enough
 
-RTK retains the full unfiltered output, so you don't have to guess and you
-shouldn't thrash: re-run that one command raw (or `rtk proxy <cmd>`) to see
+On failure, RTK's tee fallback already kept the full output. Otherwise don't
+guess or thrash: re-run that one command raw (or `rtk proxy <cmd>`) to see
 everything, then move on. One deliberate re-run is fine; blind repeated re-runs
 erase the savings.
 

README.md

@@ -11,9 +11,10 @@ learns your coding style.
 Command Code CLI reads `~/.commandcode/AGENTS.md` and injects it into the system
 prompt for every session. This repository provides that AGENTS.md file (plus a
 loadable skill), teaching Command Code to route **noisy** shell output through
-`rtk` while keeping **full fidelity** for output it needs exactly. The fastest
-setup is RTK's auto-rewrite hook (`rtk init -g`), which rewrites commands for you
-so nothing has to be prefixed by hand.
+`rtk` while keeping **full fidelity** for output it needs exactly. `rtk init`
+doesn't target Command Code yet, so the working default is this memory file — the
+agent prefixes commands itself; register a Command Code `PreToolUse` hook and RTK
+can rewrite them for you automatically.
 
 ```
 Without RTK:                                 With RTK:
@@ -40,14 +41,15 @@ command.
 
 Two design choices keep it net-positive:
 
-- **Lossless by default.** Plain `rtk <cmd>` preserves errors, stack traces, diff
-  hunks, and exit codes; the lossy modes (`-u` / `--ultra-compact`, `-l
-  aggressive`, `rtk smart`) are opt-in for skimming only — never the default. On
-  output it can't parse, RTK falls back to the full raw text.
+- **Signal-preserving by default.** Plain `rtk <cmd>` keeps errors, stack traces,
+  diff hunks, and exit codes and strips only noise; the lossy modes (`-u` /
+  `--ultra-compact`, `-l aggressive`, `rtk smart`) are opt-in for skimming only —
+  never the default. If a command fails or RTK can't parse its output, you get the
+  full raw text back (tee fallback).
 - **Measure net, not gross.** `rtk gain` reports gross savings; the goal is *net*
   — savings minus any re-runs and minus the standing cost of these instructions.
-  `rtk gain --failures` and `rtk discover` show where RTK fits and where it
-  doesn't (see [references/analytics.md](references/analytics.md)).
+  `rtk discover` shows where RTK fits and where savings run low (see
+  [references/analytics.md](references/analytics.md)).
 
 This matters for quality too: every frontier model degrades as irrelevant context
 grows ("context rot" / "lost in the middle"), so cutting genuine noise can *help*
@@ -70,10 +72,11 @@ the first and avoid the second.
 > enforcement, install the memory (Method 2); the skill (Method 1) is the
 > quickest install and is enough when you mainly want it during shell-heavy work.
 
-> **Even better — the auto-rewrite hook.** RTK can install a `PreToolUse` hook
-> (`rtk init -g`) that rewrites Bash commands to `rtk` automatically, so the agent
-> never prefixes anything by hand. Pair it with the memory or skill below, which
-> carry the *when-to-compress* rules. See `rtk init --help`.
+> **Optional — the auto-rewrite hook.** A `PreToolUse` hook can rewrite Bash
+> commands to `rtk` automatically so the agent never prefixes by hand. Note that
+> RTK's `rtk init` installer doesn't target Command Code yet (`rtk init -g` wires
+> up Claude Code/Copilot), so for Command Code you'd register the hook yourself.
+> Until then, Method 2 below is the reliable path. See `rtk init --help`.
 
 ### Method 1: Skill (quick install, on-demand)
 
@@ -125,7 +128,7 @@ leaves precise output alone:
 
 | Category | Command | Through RTK? | Est. savings |
 |---|---|---|---|
-| Status / listings | `rtk git status`, `rtk ls`, `rtk tree` | 🟢 yes | ~80% |
+| Status / listings | `rtk git status`, `rtk ls`, `rtk git log` | 🟢 yes | ~80% |
 | Logs / containers | `rtk docker ps`, `rtk log app.log` | 🟢 yes | ~80% |
 | Dependencies | `rtk pip list`, `rtk pnpm list` | 🟢 yes | ~70% |
 | Tests / build | `rtk cargo test`, `rtk err <cmd>` | 🟡 plain mode (keeps failures) | ~90% |
@@ -134,7 +137,7 @@ leaves precise output alone:
 | Files you'll edit | native Read tool | 🔴 not RTK | — |
 
 _Savings are illustrative; actual numbers vary by command and output size. Run
-`rtk gain` to measure your own — and `rtk gain --failures` to spot poor fits._
+`rtk gain` to measure your own — and `rtk discover` to spot poor fits._
 
 See [references/commands.md](references/commands.md) for the full tiered list and
 [references/analytics.md](references/analytics.md) for measuring net savings.
@@ -148,8 +151,8 @@ rtk gain --graph        # Visual savings chart
 
 After running a few commands through Command Code, `rtk gain` will show the
 accumulated savings. Track **net** savings, not just the headline number:
-`rtk gain --failures` lists commands RTK had to pass through raw (poor fits), and
-`rtk discover` finds new high-value targets. See
+`rtk discover` finds new high-value targets and low-savings outliers, and RTK's
+tee fallback keeps full output whenever a command fails. See
 [references/analytics.md](references/analytics.md).
 
 ## Files

SKILL.md

@@ -39,21 +39,23 @@ the winning side.
 
 ## Install — two ways
 
-### 1. Auto-rewrite hook (recommended)
+### 1. Auto-rewrite hook (best where supported)
 
-Let a `PreToolUse` hook rewrite Bash commands to their `rtk` equivalents
-automatically, so you never prefix by hand and nothing gets forgotten. RTK ships
-this for natively-supported agents:
+A `PreToolUse` hook rewrites Bash commands to their `rtk` equivalents
+automatically, so you never prefix by hand and nothing gets forgotten:
 
 ```bash
 rtk init -g          # installs the PreToolUse rewrite hook, then restart the agent
 ```
 
-RTK natively targets Claude Code, Copilot, Cursor, Gemini, Cline, and more.
-Command Code also supports `PreToolUse` hooks — register one that pipes the Bash
+**Caveat for Command Code:** `rtk init`'s agent list is Claude Code, Copilot,
+Cursor, Gemini, Cline, and more — it does **not** include Command Code yet, so
+`rtk init -g` wires up Claude Code/Copilot, not Command Code. Command Code does
+support `PreToolUse` hooks, so you can register one yourself that pipes the Bash
 command through RTK's rewrite (see the Command Code hooks docs and `rtk init
---help`). With a hook installed you **run normal commands**, and only need the
-fidelity rules below for the cases where you want to *bypass* compression.
+--help`). Until Command Code is supported upstream, Method 2 is the reliable path.
+With a hook installed you **run normal commands** and only need the fidelity rules
+below to *bypass* compression.
 
 ### 2. Manual prefixing (no hook)
 
@@ -78,7 +80,7 @@ Full tiered table: [references/commands.md](references/commands.md).
 Use the *least* compression that still answers the question:
 
 ```
-raw / native Read  →  rtk <cmd> (near-lossless, default)  →  -u / -l aggressive / rtk smart (lossy, skim-only)
+raw / native Read  →  rtk <cmd> (keeps signal, default)  →  -u / -l aggressive / rtk smart (lossy, skim-only)
 ```
 
 Start as far left as the task needs. Escalate compression only for big, boring
@@ -96,9 +98,10 @@ blindly.
 
 ## Measure net savings
 
-`rtk gain` shows gross savings; `rtk gain --failures` shows what passed through
-raw; `rtk discover` finds good new targets. Optimize **net** tokens (savings
-minus re-runs), not the headline number. Full reference:
+`rtk gain` shows gross savings; `rtk discover` finds good new targets (and
+low-savings outliers worth dropping); on failure RTK's tee fallback keeps the
+full output. Optimize **net** tokens (savings minus re-runs), not the headline
+number. Full reference:
 [references/analytics.md](references/analytics.md).
 
 ## Prerequisite

references/analytics.md

@@ -10,17 +10,18 @@ context. Optimize for net.
 | `rtk gain` | session summary: tokens saved, efficiency |
 | `rtk gain --graph` | 30-day savings trend |
 | `rtk gain --history` | per-command savings — see where RTK actually pays off |
-| `rtk gain --failures` | commands RTK **couldn't parse** and passed through raw |
+| `rtk gain --quota` | monthly quota savings estimate |
 | `rtk discover` | find *good* new opportunities (don't blanket-apply) |
 | `rtk session` | RTK adoption across recent sessions |
 | `rtk gain --all --format json` | export for dashboards (run raw if you'll parse it) |
 
 ## Reading the signal
 
 - **High `--history` savings on noisy commands** → working as intended; keep going.
-- **Entries in `--failures`** → RTK fell back to raw output for those, so they
-  aren't saving — and may be a poor fit (structured or edge-case commands). Run
-  them raw and stop wrapping them.
+- **Low or zero savings on a command** (visible in `--history`, or surfaced by
+  `rtk discover`) → it's a poor fit; run it raw and stop wrapping it. And when a
+  command *fails*, RTK's tee fallback (`[tee] mode = "failures"`) has already
+  saved the full output — so you never lose error detail on the cases that matter.
 - **You re-ran a command raw right after its `rtk` version** → that pair was a net
   *loss*. Note the command type and stop compressing it.
 - **`rtk discover`** surfaces high-volume, noisy commands worth wrapping — a far

references/commands.md

@@ -15,7 +15,7 @@ skimming something huge and unimportant.
 ## 🟢 Compress freely (skim-only output)
 | Instead of | Use | Why it's safe |
 |---|---|---|
-| `ls -la`, `tree` | `rtk ls`, `rtk tree` | listings dedup/group cleanly |
+| `ls -la` | `rtk ls` | listings dedup/group cleanly |
 | `git status`, `git log -n 20` | `rtk git status`, `rtk git log -n 20` | already summaries |
 | `docker ps`, `docker images` | `rtk docker ps`, `rtk docker images` | tabular, repetitive |
 | `docker logs <c>`, `kubectl logs <p>` | `rtk docker logs <c>`, `rtk kubectl logs <p>` | dedups repeated lines |
@@ -38,7 +38,7 @@ the `file:line` you need, which forces a re-run that costs more than it saved.
 | Situation | Do this | Why |
 |---|---|---|
 | A diff/patch you'll apply | `git diff`, `git show` **raw** | exact bytes and line numbers matter |
-| Output you'll parse (JSON, `--format`) | run raw; `rtk json file --keys-only` only to *explore* structure | compression can corrupt structure |
+| Output you'll parse (JSON, `--format`) | run raw; use `rtk json file` only to *explore* structure | compression can corrupt structure |
 | Small output (≲30 lines) | run raw | nothing to save, real risk |
 | Secrets / credentials / exact config | run raw | never reason about a lossy view |
 | A file you'll **edit** | native Read tool | lossless + line numbers; bypasses RTK anyway |
@@ -47,7 +47,7 @@ the `file:line` you need, which forces a re-run that costs more than it saved.
 ## Analytics
 
 Measuring real savings — and spotting bad fits before they cost you — lives in
-[analytics.md](analytics.md): `rtk gain`, `rtk gain --failures`, `rtk discover`.
+[analytics.md](analytics.md): `rtk gain`, `rtk discover`, and the tee fallback.
 
 > RTK supports 100+ commands. Run `rtk --help` for the full set; the tiers above
 > are the decision rule, not an exhaustive list. When a command isn't listed,